Family of Dead Indonesian Maid in Shock
Melisa Kok
Singapore. The family members of the Indonesian woman, who took her own life after failing an entry test for maids thrice, have buried her in their home town of Kluwan in Central Java. But they are still in shock over their loss.
Sulastri Wardoyo, 26, had hanged herself at the maid hostel where she was staying last Saturday, after failing three times to pass a test that would have let her work here. (ST Photo)Sulastri Wardoyo, a married 26-year-old mother of one, had hanged herself in a shower stall in a maid hostel here on May 28. She died in hospital a few days later.
Her husband, who gave his name only as Sudarsono, told The Straits Times in a telephone interview: 'Up to today, we don't believe she committed suicide. She was a strong woman; she wouldn't do something like that.'
The 27-year-old farmer had been told on May 31 by his wife's Indonesian recruiter that she had been hospitalized, and then told the next day that she had died.
Her body was flown back last Friday and buried on the same day.
It is believed that Sulastri became despondent when she failed to clear the written English test of literacy and numeracy skills.
All newly arrived maids have to pass the test within three days of their arrival, among other requirements, before they are cleared to work in Singapore.
If they fail it, they are sent home.
Sudarsono said there were no problems at home. He described his late wife as a strong-hearted woman who was very close to her family and ever ready to help her friends.
'While being trained at the training centre before she went to Singapore, she called us every Saturday and Sunday to ask how we were doing. She was also supportive of her friends who were also undergoing training with her at the centre,' he said.
Indonesians looking to become maids in Singapore for the first time undergo around three months of training, which covers areas such as spoken English and performing household chores.
Sudarsono said his wife did not face difficulties during her training, but added that they had not been in touch since her arrival here.
Their daughter, 11/2-year-old Afeka Fapeana Kusumu Dewi, is now being cared for by Sulastri's parents.
The child misses her mother, said Sudarsono. 'She cries all the time, asking, 'Where is mother?' She is confused.'
He said his wife had borrowed about 7 million rupiah (S$1,000) from relatives to come to Singapore to work.
When asked if he had to pay the money back, he said: 'We discussed it as a family. They understand.'
He said he is not sure who will have to foot his wife's hospital bills, but added matter-of-factly: 'Right now, I think it's my responsibility.'
Bridget Tan, president of the Humanitarian Organization for Migration Economics, said she and a few representatives of the migrant worker welfare group will visit Sudarsono and his family next week with an offer of assistance.
She added that she was also looking to start a public donation drive to raise funds for Sulastri's family.
The Indonesian woman's death has turned the spotlight on the entry test for foreign domestic workers, with many maid agencies and employers calling for it to be either reviewed or scrapped.
The Manpower Ministry said on Monday that it is reviewing the test, following feedback it has received over the last few months.
Source: The Jakarta Globe - Wednesday, June 8, 2011
Staff claimed that she had been depressed over her trice failure in the English-language, preventing her from working in the city-state.
Singapore Entry Test for Maids 'Too Difficult'
Elizabeth Soh
Singapore. About 50 maids sat the test - and only five passed.
That was the dismal result yesterday when the latest batch of newly arrived maids took the Foreign Domestic Worker Entry Test.
They must pass the test before they can work here, and are given three tries, failing which they must leave Singapore. But they can come back to retake the test.
Last Saturday, an Indonesian maid, who was said to be depressed after failing the test three times, tried to hang herself.
Every weekday, about 80 maids take the test in batches at the Mountbatten office of Grace Management, which has been contracted by the Ministry of Manpower (MOM) to conduct the tests.
The test was introduced in 2005 as part of measures by MOM to improve the literacy and numeracy skills of maids here. In 2009, the questions were revised following an MOM review.
Maids have 30 minutes to answer 40 multiple choice questions in English. The questions test their understanding of English as well as in areas like household chores, budgeting and childcare.
At the centre yesterday, the mix of Indonesian, Filipino and Myanmar maids looked nervous while waiting for their results. Some were already crying while others clutched well-thumbed folders containing sheets of sample questions and answers that they had studied.
Maids awaiting the results of the entry test yesterday. They must pass the test before they can work here, and are given three tries, failing which they must leave Singapore. MOM says the test has helped to ensure that more mature and literate maids come here. (ST Photo/Wang Huifen) The results were out within half an hour and, according to the agents there, all except five maids failed. It was the second or third attempt for most.
MOM has said the passing rate for the test has consistently been 95 per cent. But agents said that based on what they have observed, the rate is much lower.
'Each day, at least half will fail,' said an agent who was at the centre. 'Some are taking the test for the 20th time. They will just keep trying because the cost is too much for them to give up.'
Filipino and Sri Lankan maids are repatriated if they fail and have to face the disappointment of families, who often have to sell their cattle or homes to pay for them to come here.
Most Indonesian maids are sent to Batam to be retrained before they take the ferry back - often at their own expense - to try again. Almost all owe at least $1,000 to their agents back home.
Myanmar maid Bawk Nu, 23, was one of the few who cleared the test yesterday. It was her first attempt. 'I was not confident of passing, I was so scared,' she said in a mix of English and Mandarin. 'I'm very happy I can be a maid now.'
Twenty employment agencies interviewed said the passing rates ranged from 60 per cent for Myanmar and Indonesian maids to 90 per cent for Filipino ones.
Filipino maid Felicita Fernandez, 41, started to cry 10 minutes before the results were out. She was taking the test for the third time. 'If I fail this time, I will have to go back to the Philippines,' said the mother of four. 'I have no money and I will now owe more.'
Unfortunately, she failed.
About 10 maids interviewed at the centre said they did not understand most of the questions. While most were able to read them, they did not understand the content.
'I tikam the paper,' said Indonesian maid Sumiyati, 23, referring to how she made wild guesses. She showed how she circled the answers randomly.
Employment agencies said the test became too tough after it was revised. A common complaint was that it now features far fewer illustrations and pictures.
Peter Chan of Javamaids said: 'Passing the entry test also does not mean that they can converse in English. And no matter how much we train the girls in other areas like cooking, it's useless if they can't pass the test.'
Suhaila Musao of Yathrib Services said: 'The real value in the training is the practical lessons like ironing and cooking. But the maids are so frustrated and pressured about the test that they cannot focus.'
An MOM spokesman said the test has helped ensure that more mature and literate maids come to Singapore. It is conducted in English because public signs and labels are generally in that language.
Several employers said that while an entry test was important, what was more useful than a maid's ability to speak English were skills like being able to look after the elderly and children and cook basic meals.
'I want a maid with a good learning attitude and good hygiene, who can cook and take care of my family,' said marketing executive Josephine Teo, 54.
'Speaking English is a plus, but also something she can learn over time.'
Source: The Jakarta Globe - June 2, 2011
MOM Reviewing Effectives Of Entry Test For Maids
WE REFER to recent letters and articles in The Straits Times on the entry test for first-time foreign domestic workers (FDWs), following the tragic demise of Ms Sulastri Wardoyo.
The Ministry of Manpower (MOM) introduced the entry test in 2005 as part of a package of measures to ensure first-time FDWs are able to adapt to working and living in Singapore.
The entry test was thus designed to ensure that they possess basic numeracy and literacy skills. It also helps ascertain the ability of FDWs to understand basic safety instructions, as most of them will be working in a highly urbanised environment for the first time.
This is important, both for the safety of the FDW as well as the young children and the elderly she may be taking care of.
Contrary to suggestions by some employment agencies, MOM has not made the entry test more difficult in recent months or years. It is also inaccurate to draw conclusions about the passing rate from a single test session, as your newspaper did ('Entry test for maids 'too difficult''; last Thursday).
In fact, close to 95 per cent of first-time FDWs pass the test. To better assess whether a potential FDW can pass the entry test, employment agencies may use the sample test questions available on MOM's website.
The ministry has been receiving suggestions and ideas on the entry test in recent months, in part due to policy changes in the FDW source countries. MOM is reviewing the effectiveness of the entry test to ensure it remains relevant, while taking into consideration the feedback received.
We will work with key stakeholders as part of the review. Members of the public can e-mail suggestions and views to mom_fmmd@mom.gov.sg
Farah Abdul Rahim (Ms)
Director, Corporate Communications
Ministry of Manpower
Source: Asia One - Tuesday, June 7, 2011
Melisa Kok
Singapore. The family members of the Indonesian woman, who took her own life after failing an entry test for maids thrice, have buried her in their home town of Kluwan in Central Java. But they are still in shock over their loss.
Sulastri Wardoyo, 26, had hanged herself at the maid hostel where she was staying last Saturday, after failing three times to pass a test that would have let her work here. (ST Photo)Her husband, who gave his name only as Sudarsono, told The Straits Times in a telephone interview: 'Up to today, we don't believe she committed suicide. She was a strong woman; she wouldn't do something like that.'
The 27-year-old farmer had been told on May 31 by his wife's Indonesian recruiter that she had been hospitalized, and then told the next day that she had died.
Her body was flown back last Friday and buried on the same day.
It is believed that Sulastri became despondent when she failed to clear the written English test of literacy and numeracy skills.
All newly arrived maids have to pass the test within three days of their arrival, among other requirements, before they are cleared to work in Singapore.
If they fail it, they are sent home.
Sudarsono said there were no problems at home. He described his late wife as a strong-hearted woman who was very close to her family and ever ready to help her friends.
'While being trained at the training centre before she went to Singapore, she called us every Saturday and Sunday to ask how we were doing. She was also supportive of her friends who were also undergoing training with her at the centre,' he said.
Indonesians looking to become maids in Singapore for the first time undergo around three months of training, which covers areas such as spoken English and performing household chores.
Sudarsono said his wife did not face difficulties during her training, but added that they had not been in touch since her arrival here.
Their daughter, 11/2-year-old Afeka Fapeana Kusumu Dewi, is now being cared for by Sulastri's parents.
The child misses her mother, said Sudarsono. 'She cries all the time, asking, 'Where is mother?' She is confused.'
He said his wife had borrowed about 7 million rupiah (S$1,000) from relatives to come to Singapore to work.
When asked if he had to pay the money back, he said: 'We discussed it as a family. They understand.'
He said he is not sure who will have to foot his wife's hospital bills, but added matter-of-factly: 'Right now, I think it's my responsibility.'
Bridget Tan, president of the Humanitarian Organization for Migration Economics, said she and a few representatives of the migrant worker welfare group will visit Sudarsono and his family next week with an offer of assistance.
She added that she was also looking to start a public donation drive to raise funds for Sulastri's family.
The Indonesian woman's death has turned the spotlight on the entry test for foreign domestic workers, with many maid agencies and employers calling for it to be either reviewed or scrapped.
The Manpower Ministry said on Monday that it is reviewing the test, following feedback it has received over the last few months.
Source: The Jakarta Globe - Wednesday, June 8, 2011
******
Officials on Friday vowed to review training programs for migrant workers as news reached the country that Sulastri Wardoyo had attempted suicide and died in the hospital.
Asia-Pacific director for protection at the National Board for the Placement and Protection of Indonesian Overseas Workers (BNP2RKI), Sadono, said the state would ensure that workers were prepared for life abroad before approving their permits.
Aside from language skills, Sulastri’s case highlighted the need to prepare workers mentally for the stresses of life abroad.
Workers who have not completed their training cannot be placed in any country to avoid any problem over the lack of skills or language training.
Sulastri was housed by employment agency Budget Maid in a hostel, in north of Singapore.
She took the Foreign Domestic Worker Entry Test on Wednesday, Thursday and Friday but failed every time.
She then tried to commit suicide by hanging herself in a shower cubicle at the maid hostel where she was staying on Saturday.
After she was found, staff cut the rope used to hang herself.
Her heart stopped three times as paramedics tried to resuscitate her.
She was then admitted to intensive care at Khoo Teck Puat Hospital since Saturday after the attempted suicide.
She was said to have suffered brain damage after scanning, and passed away last Wednesday, after being confined in intensive care.
Severe brain damage can occur when the brain is deprived of oxygen for more than two minutes and such patients would be in a comatose state and can have difficulty breathing.
The Indonesian government was urged to find out why Sulastri failed the test.
It is important too, for the government to craft pro-training policies, and national discussion is needed as it acknowledge that training programs are still weak.
The government needs to evaluate the migrant-worker training system locally.
It would even be better if the government will also be involved in giving training to the migrant workers to improve the quality of the workers sent abroad.
For now, the government requires private recruitment agencies to give preparation courses and teaches skills for workers and state bodies.
But the state is encouraged not to depend on recruiters to provide quality instruction.
Executive director of Migrant Care, Anis Hidayah, needs the Indonesian government to “tighten supervision” of placement agencies and evaluate the preparations provided by these agencies.
She added, migrant workers’ readiness should be measured by their ability to speak the language of their employer country, their completion of administrative requirements and the skills they need for the job.******
Singapore Entry Test for Maids 'Too Difficult'
Elizabeth Soh
Singapore. About 50 maids sat the test - and only five passed.
That was the dismal result yesterday when the latest batch of newly arrived maids took the Foreign Domestic Worker Entry Test.
They must pass the test before they can work here, and are given three tries, failing which they must leave Singapore. But they can come back to retake the test.
Last Saturday, an Indonesian maid, who was said to be depressed after failing the test three times, tried to hang herself.
Every weekday, about 80 maids take the test in batches at the Mountbatten office of Grace Management, which has been contracted by the Ministry of Manpower (MOM) to conduct the tests.
The test was introduced in 2005 as part of measures by MOM to improve the literacy and numeracy skills of maids here. In 2009, the questions were revised following an MOM review.
Maids have 30 minutes to answer 40 multiple choice questions in English. The questions test their understanding of English as well as in areas like household chores, budgeting and childcare.
At the centre yesterday, the mix of Indonesian, Filipino and Myanmar maids looked nervous while waiting for their results. Some were already crying while others clutched well-thumbed folders containing sheets of sample questions and answers that they had studied.
Maids awaiting the results of the entry test yesterday. They must pass the test before they can work here, and are given three tries, failing which they must leave Singapore. MOM says the test has helped to ensure that more mature and literate maids come here. (ST Photo/Wang Huifen) MOM has said the passing rate for the test has consistently been 95 per cent. But agents said that based on what they have observed, the rate is much lower.
'Each day, at least half will fail,' said an agent who was at the centre. 'Some are taking the test for the 20th time. They will just keep trying because the cost is too much for them to give up.'
Filipino and Sri Lankan maids are repatriated if they fail and have to face the disappointment of families, who often have to sell their cattle or homes to pay for them to come here.
Most Indonesian maids are sent to Batam to be retrained before they take the ferry back - often at their own expense - to try again. Almost all owe at least $1,000 to their agents back home.
Myanmar maid Bawk Nu, 23, was one of the few who cleared the test yesterday. It was her first attempt. 'I was not confident of passing, I was so scared,' she said in a mix of English and Mandarin. 'I'm very happy I can be a maid now.'
Twenty employment agencies interviewed said the passing rates ranged from 60 per cent for Myanmar and Indonesian maids to 90 per cent for Filipino ones.
Filipino maid Felicita Fernandez, 41, started to cry 10 minutes before the results were out. She was taking the test for the third time. 'If I fail this time, I will have to go back to the Philippines,' said the mother of four. 'I have no money and I will now owe more.'
Unfortunately, she failed.
About 10 maids interviewed at the centre said they did not understand most of the questions. While most were able to read them, they did not understand the content.
'I tikam the paper,' said Indonesian maid Sumiyati, 23, referring to how she made wild guesses. She showed how she circled the answers randomly.
Employment agencies said the test became too tough after it was revised. A common complaint was that it now features far fewer illustrations and pictures.
Peter Chan of Javamaids said: 'Passing the entry test also does not mean that they can converse in English. And no matter how much we train the girls in other areas like cooking, it's useless if they can't pass the test.'
Suhaila Musao of Yathrib Services said: 'The real value in the training is the practical lessons like ironing and cooking. But the maids are so frustrated and pressured about the test that they cannot focus.'
An MOM spokesman said the test has helped ensure that more mature and literate maids come to Singapore. It is conducted in English because public signs and labels are generally in that language.
Several employers said that while an entry test was important, what was more useful than a maid's ability to speak English were skills like being able to look after the elderly and children and cook basic meals.
'I want a maid with a good learning attitude and good hygiene, who can cook and take care of my family,' said marketing executive Josephine Teo, 54.
'Speaking English is a plus, but also something she can learn over time.'
Source: The Jakarta Globe - June 2, 2011
******
MOM Reviewing Effectives Of Entry Test For Maids
WE REFER to recent letters and articles in The Straits Times on the entry test for first-time foreign domestic workers (FDWs), following the tragic demise of Ms Sulastri Wardoyo.
The Ministry of Manpower (MOM) introduced the entry test in 2005 as part of a package of measures to ensure first-time FDWs are able to adapt to working and living in Singapore.
The entry test was thus designed to ensure that they possess basic numeracy and literacy skills. It also helps ascertain the ability of FDWs to understand basic safety instructions, as most of them will be working in a highly urbanised environment for the first time.
This is important, both for the safety of the FDW as well as the young children and the elderly she may be taking care of.
Contrary to suggestions by some employment agencies, MOM has not made the entry test more difficult in recent months or years. It is also inaccurate to draw conclusions about the passing rate from a single test session, as your newspaper did ('Entry test for maids 'too difficult''; last Thursday).
In fact, close to 95 per cent of first-time FDWs pass the test. To better assess whether a potential FDW can pass the entry test, employment agencies may use the sample test questions available on MOM's website.
The ministry has been receiving suggestions and ideas on the entry test in recent months, in part due to policy changes in the FDW source countries. MOM is reviewing the effectiveness of the entry test to ensure it remains relevant, while taking into consideration the feedback received.
We will work with key stakeholders as part of the review. Members of the public can e-mail suggestions and views to mom_fmmd@mom.gov.sg
Farah Abdul Rahim (Ms)
Director, Corporate Communications
Ministry of Manpower
Source: Asia One - Tuesday, June 7, 2011
